It Happened One Night (1934)

"Immigrants get it done!!" I just saw the musical Hamilton last night and that line resonated with me (and drew cheers from the audience).  The word 'immigrants' has been unfairly dragged through the mud by a certain political party lately. Immigrants are a huge part of the fabric of the United States.  Immigrants helped to build America and make our country unique and diverse.  And if it wasn't for one particular immigrant, we may not have met characters like George Bailey from IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE (1946), "Long John" Willoughby in MEET JOHN DOE (1944), or Jefferson Smith in MR. SMITH GOES TO WASHINGTON (1939). The immigrant responsible for these classic films was director Frank Capra, born in Sicily in 1897 and who immigrated to New York and eventually southern California with his family in 1903. 

Capra began his film career as a comedy writer for Mack Sennett silent films and moved to directing films in the late 1920s including LADIES OF LEISURE (1930) with a then unknown Barbara Stanwyck.  Capra's first big hit was IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT (1934), the prototype for the romantic comedy that has been used over and over again to this day. The fact that IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT would be as successful as it was is a testament to Capra's immigrant grit and optimism. Neither stars Clark Gable nor Claudette Colbert wanted to be in the comedy.  IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT was under the banner of Columbia Picture, at the time considered a poverty row studio headed by Harry Cohn. To the amazement of everyone involved, IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT would go on to win the 5 major Academy Awards in 1934: Best Picture, Best Actor (Gable), Best Actress (Colbert), Best Adapted Screenplay (Robert Riskin), and Best Director (Frank Capra).  Only Milos Foreman's ONE FLEW OVER THE CUKOO'S NEST (1975) and Jonathan Demme's THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS (1991) have repeated this incredible feat. 

With an adapted screenplay by Robert Riskin (MR. DEEDS COMES TO TOWN) based on a short story called Night Bus by Samuel Hopkins Adams and directed by Frank Capra, IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT begins with a splash (literally). Banished to her tycoon father Alexander Andrews (Walter Connolly) yacht in Florida after secretly marrying the fortune seeking weasel King Westley (Jameson Thomas) without her father's blessing, spoiled daughter and heiress Ellie Andrews (Claudette Colbert) jumps ship, swimming to land and avoiding her father's men. Ellie turns up at the bus station and buys (with the help of a nice little old lady) a one-way ticket from Miami to New York. At the back of the bus, Ellie sits next to newspaper reporter Peter Warne (Clark Gable) who has just been fired by his editor Joe Gordon (Charles C. Wilson). At their first rest stop, Ellie's suitcase is stolen. Peter chases after the thief (Ernie Adams) who eludes him. Ellie doesn't want to report the theft.  Peter begins to wonder who this nicely dressed woman is and what has she done.

At the next stop, Ellie naively asks Bus Driver #1 (a young Ward Bond) to wait for her while she runs an errand. Upon her return, she discovers the bus has left but Peter is waiting for her. Peter knows her real identity. Ellie's story is all over the front pages of every newspaper including the one Peter holds. Peter has a scoop in his hands. He sends a telegram (charges reversed) to his editor Joe that he has a hot story. Ellie and Peter catch another bus to New York. Ellie finds herself next to the annoying Oscar Shapeley (Roscoe Karns) who hits on the attractive traveler. Peter steps in and pretends to be Ellie's husband. Oscar backs off. A bridge is washed out along the bus route. Peter secures a room for Ellie and himself at a motel. It has two beds. Peter puts up a blanket between them, calling it the "Walls of Jericho" (a wonderful sexual innuendo that pays off at the end). Peter offers Ellie a deal. He wants the inside story on King Westley or he threatens to turn Ellie in to her father.

So begins the original opposites attract tale of a coddled socialite and a hard nosed reporter that we love in romantic comedies like IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT. Peter loans Ellie his pajamas for the night. He begins to undress in front of Ellie before she realizes what he's doing and retreats to her side of the room. When she wakes up the next morning, Peter has had her dress pressed and made breakfast for her. Ellie begins to let down her guard for the irascible Peter. Two detectives show up, snooping around for Ellie. Peter and Ellie pretend to bicker like a married couple inside their room, driving the detectives away. Back on the bus, Oscar sees the headline about Ellie and her father's reward to find her. Oscar tries to squeeze Peter into sharing the reward with him. Peter scares Oscar away with a fake kidnapping plot. A party blossoms on the bus with music and dancing causing the bus to crash into a swamp. After sleeping in a farmer's barn for the night, Peter and Ellie hit the road and try hitchhiking. Peter has no luck with his thumb. Ellie gives it a try and (famously) flashes her bare leg. The next car driven by a jolly man named Danker (Alan Hale) immediately screeches to a halt.

Danker drives them closer to New York. When they make a stop, Danker tries to drive away with their luggage. Peter chases Danker down and takes his car after a fight. Mr. Andrews flies to New York and makes a deal with King. He won't interfere with his daughter's marriage. He just wants a proper real wedding. Ellie's not in a hurry to get to New York. She and Peter stay at another motel outside Philadelphia. Ellie breaks down and professes her love to Peter.  While she sleeps, Peter races to New York and borrows some money from Joe so he can marry Ellie. The motel owners burst into Ellie's room and kick her out, believing Peter has left without paying. Ellie thinks Peter has ditched her. She calls her father who arrives with King in a police escort to take her home. Peter returns and sees the motorcade pass him with Ellie. He turns around but can't catch them. Mr. Andrews and Ellie have a frank conversation. Ellie admits she's in love with another man named Peter. Mr. Andrews has a letter from Peter about the reward. Ellie's heartbroken. She thinks Peter just wanted the reward. When Peter meets with Mr. Andrews before the wedding, he just wants reimbursement for the gas and motels. He doesn't want the reward. Peter confesses to Mr. Andrews he loves her daughter. Will Mr. Andrews share this admission to Ellie before she's at the altar with King? Will Peter and Ellie knock  down the "Walls of Jericho?" 

The birth of the classic romantic comedy may have begun with IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT. Today's movie fans will recognize two protagonists (one male; one female) who have nothing in common that meet by chance and initially, can't stand each other. Ellie is the spoiled rich girl who's never been out in the real world. Peter's the blue collar, hard drinking reporter with integrity. Unlike screwball comedies like  Howard Hawks BRINGING UP BABY (1933), IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT focuses on plot instead of rapid fire dialogue (although Riskin's dialogue is priceless). IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT does deal with class (elite vs blue collar) that audiences loved. It turns into a road movie as Ellie and Peter move from bus to hitchhiking to automobile as they begin to fall in love with each other. What makes IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT a cut above other romantic comedies later in the 30s is it was made Pre-Code. It's sexy and daring and provocative. The strict Hayes Code had not put the clamps on cinematic sexual foreplay yet. 

Claudette Colbert showing her bare leg and thigh to catch a passing car's attention and hitch a ride became IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT'S most iconic image and famous few frames of film. By today's standards, it's tame. But in 1934, Colbert using her sexuality to acquire transportation after Gable's thumb failed is a powerful tool that censors would soon put a stop to. Another risque scene involves Lombard and Gable sharing a motel room (albeit separate beds). Gable undresses in front of Colbert, showing her his preference of which items of clothing come off first. Colbert retreats to her side of the room in horror which leads to Gable's idea of hanging a blanket between their beds. "Prying eyes annoy me. Behold the Walls of Jericho. Maybe not as thick as the ones Joshua blew down with his trumpet but a lot safer." "The Walls of Jericho" is a biblical reference to a battle where the Israelites encircled the town of Jericho for six days before the walls fell down on the seventh day. Gable will have to encircle Colbert's heart until her desires cave in. 

In IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT, "the Walls of Jericho" represent a sexual innuendo that director Capra gets away with Pre-Code. Ellie and Peter can't have intercourse until either her marriage is annulled and/or Ellie and Peter get married.  Peter's hanging of the blanket aka "the Walls of Jericho" prevent them for the time from jumping into each other's pants. The "Walls of Jericho" will payoff in the film's final reel. Ellie leaves King at the altar after learning Peter does love her, jumping into a waiting car her father has left for her. Mr. Andrews reads a telegram from Peter after he and Ellie are married. They're honeymooning in a motel somewhere in Michigan. "The Walls of Jericho are toppling," Peter tells Mr. Andrews in the telegram. We never see them but the motel lights are on. The husband and wife owners giggle like school kids at what's going on in that room. The motel owner tells his wife the honeymooners requested a toy trumpet. The lights turn off and we hear the bugle briefly blare. The final shot is the blanket falling to the floor. It's a clever metaphor signifying our lovers have knocked down the barrier between them and can finally have sex. 

As I watched IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT, I realized that the film is the blueprint for two of my favorite romantic comedies that I had seen way before I ever watched Capra's gem. Both William Wyler's ROMAN HOLIDAY (1953) and Robert Zemeckis's ROMANCING THE STONE (1984) owe their romantic couples and situations to IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT. ROMAN HOLIDAY gives us another reporter, this time down on his luck international correspondent Gregory Peck who accidentally stumbles across the exclusive of a lifetime when he comes across AWOL princess Audrey Hepburn who has snook away from her royal handlers while visiting Rome. Peck and Hepburn will briefly fall in love but realize that a commoner and a royal can never live happily ever after. ROMANCING THE STONE introduces two completely opposite characters: a meek romance novelist (Kathleen Turner) and an extroverted fortune hunter (Michael Douglas) looking for her kidnapped sister. They have nothing in common and don't get along which can only mean they will fall in love with each other. Sounds like Colbert's Ellie Andrews and Gable's Peter Warne in IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT doesn't it?

For someone who didn't want to be in IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT, Clark Gable owns the movie, making struggling newspaper reporter Peter Warne one of his most engaging characters. Gable as Warne goes from defiantly drunk and despondent after he's fired by his editor to a chivalrous knight protecting the story of a lifetime when a stroke of luck has him sitting next to runaway heiress Ellie Andrews on a Greyhound bus. At first, Peter sees Ellie as his meal ticket back to legitimacy as a reporter. Peter will evolve as he falls for the spunky daughter of a millionaire who's never really been out in the real world with regular people. A leading man for his entire career, the 1930s were Gable's golden decade with IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT his first hit.  Gable would follow up with bigger films like William Wellman's CALL OF THE WILD (1935), Frank Lloyd's MUTINY ON THE BOUNTY (1935), and W.S. Van Dyke's SAN FRANCISCO (1936). Gable's rise from leading man to movie star would culminate in his most famous role as rogue Rhett Butler and his tumultuous relationship with southern belle Scarlett O'Hara (Vivian Leigh) during and after the Civil War in Victor Fleming's GONE WITH THE WIND (1939). 

Like Gable, Claudette Colbert also did not want to be in IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT and was so sure it was a bomb, she didn't even attend the Academy Awards where she won for Best Actress (apparently when she heard she had won, she rushed to the ceremony). What I find interesting about Colbert's Ellie Andrews is she doesn't really act spoiled. Ellie's just naive. She's lived a sheltered life, under the thumb of father Alexander who's bought her everything she wanted. In later romantic comedies with wealthy female protagonists, they're often more annoying and snootier to begin with before softening up to their blue collar love interest (like Goldie Hawn and Kurt Russell in OVERBOARD). Colbert seduces with her big round eyes and nonchalant sexuality.  IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT was Colbert's first big hit. Other Colbert films to check out include Cecil B. DeMille's CLEOPATRA (1934), Ernst Lubitsch's BLUEBEARD'S EIGHTH WIFE (1938), and Preston Sturges THE PALM BEACH STORY (1942), a classic screwball comedy co-starring Joel McCrea. 

After watching the first third of IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT, you would think wealthy Alexander Andrews played by Walter Connolly was the villain of the film. He keeps his daughter Ellie captive on his yacht for defying him, secretly marrying scoundrel King Westley against his wishes. He has detectives scouring the East Coast searching for her when she escapes from her water bound prison. By the end of the film, Mr. Andrews is playing matchmaker, passing on separately to both Ellie and Peter that each one is completely in love with the other. Andrews saves the day before our lovers make a terrible mistake.  The portly Walter Connolly had a relatively short career (he passed away in 1940) but stood out playing wealthy characters like Andrews. Connolly's filmography includes screwball comedies like Howard Hawks TWENTIETH CENTURY (1934) with John Barrymore and Carole Lombard and William Wellman's NOTHING SACRED (1937) with Lombard and Fredric March. 

Two of the most recognizable supporting character actors of the Golden Age have small but memorable roles in IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT.  John Ford favorite Ward Bond plays the no nonsense Bus Driver #1 who strands Ellie at a bus stop when he won't wait for her to run an errand. Bond would work with Capra again 12 years later in IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE in a memorable role as George Bailey's buddy Bert the Cop.  Alan Hale has an unusual role in his long character actor career as the singing driver Danker who picks up hitchhikers Ellie and Peter on the road and later tries to drive off with their suitcases.  Hale usually played good guys, often in numerous Michael Curtiz films including THE ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD (1938), THE SEA HAWK (1940), and VIRGINIA CITY (1940). And a special shout out to Bess Flowers who plays Joe the Editor's long suffering but strong assistant Agnes. Agnes belongs in a screwball comedy with her deadpan face as Joe berates her for accepting Peter's collect calls and reverse telegram charges, never showing any emotion. She knows Joe will never fire her even though he threatens to. According to IMDB, Flowers was known as "Queen of the Hollywood Extras" appearing in over 800 films (usually as an extra) including 25 Best Picture Nominees.

Maybe because I haven't seen many of their movies, I get Claudette Colbert and Carole Lombard mixed up.  Both were fine comedic actresses, at the top of their game in the 1930s and 40s. Both were beautiful women but they don't look very much alike. Lombard was a blonde; Colbert had dark curly hair. It's their first names caused the confusion. Claudette and Carole. Ironically, Clark Gable was married to Carole Lombard from 1939 until 1942 when Lombard tragically died in a plane crash in Nevada. 

Sadly, Claudette Colbert and Clark Gable only made one other film together Jack Conway's BOOM TOWN (1940) co-starring Spencer Tracy and Hedy LaMarr. Their chemistry is what makes IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT a hit. By contrast, Colbert would make seven films with Fred MacMurray; Gable would make six films with Jean Harlow. IT HAPPENED ONE NIGHT is Frank Capra's love letter to the romantic comedy with one of the most irresistible screen couples in film history in Colbert and Gable, planting the seed for future filmmakers to bring together two different characters with nothing in common who will take a journey and fall in love in the process. 

Blue Velvet (1986)

BLUE VELVET was my introduction to the surreal mind of director David Lynch (ERASERHEAD) who passed away a month ago in late January 2025. From the moment the titles appeared over a lush blue curtain rippling ever so slightly and Bobby Vinton crooned "she wore bluuuuuue velvet" during the opening montage, I fell down the Lynch rabbit hole and never looked back. Something in the neo noir BLUE VELVET resonated with me when I first saw it with some college friends at a film class. It was 1986.  Ronald Reagan was President. I remember Reagan touting the red, white, and blue spirit of America.  Apple pie and hot dogs. Wholesomeness. Community. Every day heroes. It seemed so perfect. But when I watched my local news or read the newspaper, I noticed a darker undercurrent. A youth soccer coach arrested for sexual misconduct with a player. A PTA treasurer embezzling school funds. A district attorney murdered after a clandestine meeting with an escort. 

What BLUE VELVET revealed was that past the white picket fences and shiny red fire engines we see at the start of the film was the hidden side to the Reagan Era at the time (or suburban America in general), symbolized by the camera in BLUE VELVET sinking below the perfectly manicured green lawn to reveal hundreds of teeming black beetles scurrying below the surface. There was a dark side to the American dream lurking in the underbelly of society. BLUE VELVET was the Hardy Boys meet the Marquis de Sade. My college friends and I had a tense (but brief) argument about what we had just seen. They thought it was trash. I was hypnotized by Lynch's confident style, dancing back and forth between bright goodness and dark, sadistic violence. Our friendship was frayed for a day or two until girls and Friday night parties and ESPN'S SPORT CENTER brought us back together. 

Written and directed by David Lynch, BLUE VELVET begins with Jeffrey Beaumont (Kyle McLachlan) returning to his bucolic hometown of Lumberton (actually Wilmington, North Carolina) from college after his father Mr. Beaumont (Jack Harvey) suffers a medical emergency. While walking back from the hospital through an empty field, Jeffrey comes across a severed human ear. Jeffrey takes the ear to Detective John Williams (George Dickerson) with the Lumberton Police who promises to look into it. Jeffrey grows bored hanging around home with his mother Mrs. Beaumont (Priscilla Pointer) and Aunt Barbara (Frances Bay). He goes for a night walk, ending up at Detective Williams house. Jeffrey's curious about the investigation. Detective Williams can't discuss the case with him.  As Jeffrey leaves the house, Sandy Williams (Laura Dern), the Detective and Mrs. Williams (Hope Lange) high school daughter, materializes out of the darkness. Sandy has overheard her father talking about the severed ear and its possible connection with a nightclub singer named Dorothy Vallens (Isabella Rossellini). Sandy shows Jeffrey the Deep River Apartments where Dorothy lives.

The next day, Jeffrey picks up Sandy from high school and takes her to Arlene's Diner. Jeffrey tells her his plan to impersonate a pest control worker (his father's hardware store has the cannisters) so he can access her apartment and learn more about Dorothy. Jeffrey knocks on her door. Dorothy lets him in. As Jeffrey sprays around her apartment, the Yellow Man (Fred Pickler in a mustard suit) pays Dorothy a visit. With Dorothy distracted, Jeffrey quickly grabs a spare key from underneath her counter. Jeffrey and Sandy go to the Slow Club that night to watch Dorothy perform. After the show, Jeffrey returns to Dorothy's apartment to snoop around. Dorothy returns home unexpectedly. Jeffrey hides in her closet where Dorothy discovers him. Dorothy holds a knife on Jeffrey, forcing him to strip. There's a knock at her door. Jeffrey returns to hide in the closet. The sadistic, nitrous oxide sniffing drug dealer Frank Booth (Dennis Hopper) enters. Jeffrey watches as Frank sexually abuses and rapes Dorothy before departing. Jeffrey comforts Dorothy.  Before Jeffrey departs, he finds a photograph of Dorothy's husband and son under her couch.

Jeffrey recounts most of what happened in Dorothy's apartment to Sandy. "Why is there so much trouble in this world?" Jeffrey muses.  Jeffrey visits Dorothy again and begins to follow Frank. He sees Frank and the Yellow Man enter a building where a drug deal turns deadly. Jeffrey is falling in love with Sandy while carrying on a relationship with Dorothy. Jeffrey visits Dorothy again. They make love only Dorothy wants it rough much to Jeffrey's chagrin. As Jeffrey leaves Dorothy's apartment, he runs into Frank and his posse including Raymond (Brad Dourif), Paul (Jack Nance), and Hunter (J. Michael Hunter). Frank and his crew take Jeffrey and Dorothy on a joy ride. They visit a brothel to see Ben (Dean Stockwell), a pill popping, Roy Orbison crooning, drug dealing acquaintance of Frank. Frank is keeping Dorothy's husband and child against their will at Ben's. Dorothy is allowed to see her son briefly offscreen. 

Frank and his boys drive Jeffrey and Dorothy out into the country. Frank begins to abuse Dorothy again. Jeffrey punches Frank. Frank and his gang beat up Jeffrey and leave him semi-conscious in a lumberyard. Jeffrey makes it back home and turns in all his findings to Detective Williams about Frank, the Yellow Man (who turns out to be Det. Williams partner Tom Gordon), and Dorothy. Jeffrey's done with his snooping around. Jeffrey picks up Sandy for a date.  They go to a high school party and dance and make out. On their way home, a car chases them. Jeffrey thinks it's Frank but it's Sandy's former boyfriend Mike (Ken Stovitz). They pull over at Jeffrey's house where Dorothy emerges from the shadows naked and beaten. Jeffrey and Sandy take Dorothy to Sandy's house where they call an ambulance. They can't reach Detective Williams who's involved with a raid on a drug house. Jeffrey returns to Dorothy's apartment where he finds both the Yellow Man and Dorothy's husband (missing an ear) dead. Jeffrey begins to leave when Frank (in his disguise) pulls up and sees him. Jeffrey and Frank will have a final showdown in Dorothy's apartment. 

BLUE VELVET is Jeffrey Beaumont's awakening to the light and the dark that lurks in the world and in his heart. Director Lynch peels back the underside of the sleepy logging town of Lumberton, exposing its seedier side. Jeffrey is our guide to this underworld, uncovering secrets and miscreants he never knew existed. Jeffrey has only known the decent side of his hometown. He becomes enamored by the sleazier side when he sets eyes on the raven haired lounge singer Dorothy Vallens. Forced to watch (by his own carelessness) from the closet the abhorrent sexual behavior that Frank Booth forces Dorothy to perform, Jeffrey's repulsed and excited by it. Later, when Jeffrey makes love to Dorothy, she urges him to hit her, transforming Jeffrey (briefly) into Frank Booth Jr. But Jeffrey knows he's gone too far. He has a brief breakdown back at home that helps him to expunge the corruptness that had overtaken his soul. 

The two women Jeffrey encounters in BLUE VELVET are two sides of the light vs dark that Jeffrey's battling within. Sandy Williams (Laura Dern) represents what's wholesome and decent in Lumberton. She's blonde and dresses in white and pink, her purity symbolized in these colors. Sandy tells Jeffrey about a dream she had where the world was dark because there weren't any robins. "I guess it means there is trouble 'til the robins come," she says. Dorothy Vallens (Isabelle Rossellini) is not a bad woman just a broken one. She's from the other side of the tracks (or the other side of Lincoln Street which Jeffrey's aunt warns him to stay clear of). Dorothy's a brunette (even after she takes her stage wig off) and dresses in deep blues and purples. Dorothy represents the flip side of Sandy's angelic persona even though Dorothy's behavior is the result of Frank's physical and sexual abuse. Frank has kidnapped her husband and young son as collateral in his quest to become the drug kingpin of Lumberton. Dorothy will do anything for Frank to keep her family alive. Jeffrey falls in love with Sandy yet cheats on her with Dorothy. Good vs evil. Black against white. It's the age old conflict that lurks in suburbia just as much as big cities. Lynch sums it up simply at the end when a robin lands on the Beaumont's window sill with a beetle in its beak. The robin represents good; the beetle evil. Good has triumphed. 

My favorite films always have shots, montages, or set pieces that burn into my brain and never leave. In David Lynch films, these are affectionately known as "Lynchian." BLUE VELVET has many Lynchian moments, some obscure, others more vivid. Most are visual, some aural, thanks to Lynch collaborators cinematographer Frederick Elmes and sound designer Alan Splet. BLUE VELVET'S opening montage of bright Kodachrome Norman Rockwell shots (a red fire truck and a white picket fence with yellow flowers) that dissolves into a mass of black beetles scurrying just below the green grass sets the tone. You can almost feel BLUE VELVET'S texture while watching. Dorothy's bruised pink walls in her apartment. The black as Hades hallway outside her apartment. The thick blue curtains rippling in the opening credits. The severed ear tips us off that sound (as always in a Lynch film) will be important. The ominous humming of an air conditioning unit next to Dorothy's outside stairwell. The rippling flame that extinguishes at the end of a Jeffrey nightmare. Frank's oxygen mask pumping nitrous oxide into his nose and lungs, foreshadowing heinous acts to come.

BLUE VELVET'S set pieces would set the standard for future strange sequences in David Lynch films like WILD AT HEART (1990) and MULHOLLAND DRIVE (2001) and hit television show TWIN PEAKS (1990-91). After the weird discovery of the severed ear, Lynch lulls us into a false sense we're watching a typical mystery until BLUE VELVET'S first set piece where we're forced (along with Jeffrey hiding in the closet) to watch the psychotic Frank Booth abuse and rape Dorothy. To make it stranger, Frank needs an oxygen mask to get him aroused. This bizarre scene begins with Dorothy catching Jeffrey spying on her undressing and turns the tables on Jeffrey forcing him to strip at knifepoint , teasing him before a knock on the door from Frank turns the whole scene upside down again. This was the sequence that divided my college buddies and I (briefly). Who would pay to watch this kind of sexual violence? Lynch had turned my classmates and I into voyeurs just like Jeffrey, appalled by Frank's actions but watching nonetheless.

BLUE VELVET'S second absurdist set piece begins with Frank and his gang taking Jeffrey and Dorothy to meet Ben. I always thought Ben's place was a safe house where Frank had Dorothy's husband and child stashed. It turns out it's a brothel but a brothel teleported from the 1960s. Ben's like a pimp queen, fluttering his eyes, wearing white makeup and a garish jacket with a white ruffled tuxedo shirt. The room is dark except for lava lamps. The prostitutes have beehive hairdos and cat-eye glasses. They're short or tall and not very attractive. Frank plays a cassette of Roy Orbison singing In Dreams while Ben lip syncs to the song holding a work light for a microphone. The bizarre sequences continues to an abandoned lumber yard. Frank and his crew beat up Jeffrey but not before Frank puts on red lipstick and kisses Jeffrey. Ben lip syncs to In Dreams again while a short hooker gyrates awkwardly to the music on the car's hood. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to David Lynch's world. 

Lynch's earlier mainstream films like THE ELEPHANT MAN (1980) and DUNE (1984) were harbingers of Lynch's unique and weird vision that bubble to the surface in BLUE VELVET. In THE ELEPHANT MAN, the night porter Jim (Michael Elphick) at the hospital who sells tickets to his questionable friends to gawk and party with the Elephant Man (John Hurt) reminded me of Jeffrey surrounded by Frank, Ben, and Ben's strange middle-aged prostitutes and Frank's cretinous cronies. And Baron Vladimir Harkonnen's (Kenneth McMillan) sexual predation of a male slave in DUNE finds a more real, dangerous reimagining in Dorothy's apartment when Frank pays a visit to abuse and rape Dorothy.  Both the Baron and Frank even have breathing apparatuses that aren't exactly for their health.

David Lynch would find his alter ego in Kyle McLachlan who plays amateur sleuth Jeffrey Beaumont in BLUE VELVET. Both were from small towns (Lynch was born in Missoula, Montana; McLachlan in Yakima, Washington). Lynch cast the unknown McLachlan in the pivotal role of Paul Atreides in his version of DUNE. The film (at the time) was not well received but McLachlan's solid in his first starring role. In BLUE VELVET, McLachlan finds his footing as the boyish, naive prodigal son who returns to his hometown to uncover menace he never knew existed. McLachlan even resembles Lynch in BLUE VELVET with his button up shirts to the neck and well coiffed 80s hair. Lynch would cast McLachlan as his surrogate in the widely popular (but brief) TV show TWIN PEAKS as young FBI Agent Dale Cooper. BLUE VELVET was the blueprint for TWIN PEAKS with its moody setting in the Pacific Northwest logging town of Twin Peaks as Cooper called in to investigate the murder of a high school prom queen and uncovers more sinister and quirky things about the town. 

I will speak about Lynch's love of older, classic actors (sometimes forgotten) that he would cast in his films shortly yet Lynch (and his casting director) were great at finding new talent. BLUE VELVET is a great example. Laura Dern (daughter of actors Bruce Dern and Diane Ladd) had made an impression a year earlier in Joyce Chopra's SMOOTH TALK (1985) starring Treat Williams based on a Joyce Carol Oates short story. BLUE VELVET and later Lynch's WILD AT HEART would catapult Dern into the mainstream. Dern's Sandy Williams is the angel on Jeffrey's shoulder that mostly keeps him from succumbing to the blackness he encounters. She's virginal yet not quite. Lynch would let her play a sexier, wilder, looser version of Sandy in WILD AT HEART with Nicholas Cage and Willem Dafoe.

Isabella Rossellini was best known as the daughter of actress Ingrid Bergman and Italian director Roberto Rossellini (OPEN CITY). Rossellini was modeling and a spokesmodel for Lancome when she turned to acting. After appearing in Taylor Hackford's WHITE NIGHTS (1985), Lynch cast her as the tortured lounge singer Dorothy Vallens in BLUE VELVET.  It's a brave performance from Rossellini who appears naked and abused through much of the film while maintaining her sole goal to keep her kidnapped son alive. For all of BLUE VELVET'S blackest sequences, Lynch provides the happiest moment at the film's end when we see Dorothy sitting at the park, watching her son play. 

For two other key supporting players, BLUE VELVET resurrected their careers. Dennis Hopper (son of PERRY MASON actor William Hopper) stood out early in his career in supporting roles in Stuart Rosenberg's COOL HAND LUKE (1967) and Henry Hathaway's TRUE GRIT (1969). Hopper stepped behind the camera to direct and star in the cult classic, counter culture EASY RIDER (1969) with Peter Fonda and Jack Nicholson. But after playing a drugged out photojournalist in Francis Coppola's APOCALYPSE NOW (1979), Hopper disappeared from the cinema scene. He would resurface as the terrifying criminal Frank Booth in BLUE VELVET, searing himself into critics, casting directors, and movie fans permanently with his over the top performance. Hopper's Frank is scary and menacing yet he likes a good Pabst Blue Ribbon beer over a Heineken any day of the week. After BLUE VELVET, Hopper would go on an incredible run of fine, wide-ranging performances in films like Tim Hunter's THE RIVER'S EDGE (1986), David Anspaugh's HOOSIERS (1986), Tony Scott's TRUE ROMANCE (1993), and Jan de Bont's SPEED (1994). 

Dean Stockwell who plays the eye fluttering, make up wearing pimp to Frank named Ben in BLUE VELVET started began his career as a child actor in films like Elia Kazan's GENTLEMAN'S AGREEMENT (1947) and KIM (1950) starring Errol Flynn and based on the Rudyard Kipling novel. Stockwell took a break from Hollywood in the 1960s to join the hippy movement (along with Dennis Hopper). Like Hopper, Stockwell rebounded in the 1980s. Stockwell's Ben in BLUE VELVET is the prototype for future bizarre Lynchian characters, strange and mesmerizing. Ben's living in another decade, the 50s or 60s with his ruffled tuxedo shirt and lip synching to Roy Orbison's In Dreams. Besides BLUE VELVET, Stockwell would have fine turns in Wim Wenders PARIS, TEXAS (1984) and Jonathan Demme's MARRIED TO THE MOB (1988) where he received a Best Supporting Actor nomination as a Mafia don. Stockwell, who did guest shots in television in the 70s returned to the medium in the 90s, gaining new fans on the popular sci-fi TV show QUANTUM LEAP (1989-1993) co-starring Scott Bakula. 

For a person who started out in art school, you would think Lynch might not have a sense of classic Hollywood. Yet, many of Lynch's movies and television shows have veteran actors and actresses forgotten or not seen in a while or the occasional obscure cameo or two. In Lynch's first mainstream film THE ELEPHANT MAN , he cast legends John Gielglud (JULIUS CAESAR), Anne Bancroft (THE MIRACLE WORKER), and Wendy Hiller (SEPARATE TABLES). With DUNE, Lynch cast Jose Ferrer (CYRANO DE BERGERAC), Francesca Annis (CLEOPATRA), and Freddie Jones (FRANKENSTEIN MUST BE DESTROYED). I've mentioned Hopper and Stockwell comebacks in BLUE VELVET. WILD AT HEART gave us Diane Ladd (CHINATOWN).  Veteran western actor Richard Farnsworth (TOM HORN) was the lead in Lynch's THE STRAIGHT STORY (1999). Lynch pulled from obscurity two WEST SIDE STORY stars Russ Tamblyn and Richard Beamer for his TV series TWIN PEAKS and added Piper Laurie (THE HUSTLER). John Ford stock player Hank Worden (THE SEARCHERS) even had a cameo at age 90 in TWIN PEAKS.  David Bowie had a blink and you would miss it cameo in TWIN PEAKS: FIRE WALK WITH ME  (1992) and long forgotten Robert Blake (TVs BARETTA) showed up in Lynch's LOST HIGHWAY (1997) before he was charged with murdering his wife. Lynch liked to act too. One of his final appearances was playing famed director John Ford in Steven Spielberg's autobiographical THE FABELMANS (2022).

A few final BLUE VELVET tidbits.  Actor Jack Nance first appeared in Lynch's debut film ERASERHEAD (1977) kicking off Lynch's film career. Lynch would reward Nance by casting him in DUNE, BLUE VELVET, as supporting character Pete Martell in the TV show TWIN PEAKS, and lastly LOST HIGHWAY. Sadly, Nance passed away from a head injury after an altercation with some homeless youths in 1996 in South Pasadena, CA. Lynch and composer Angelo Badalamenti first teamed up in BLUE VELVET (Badalamenti has a cameo as Dorothy's pianist at the lounge). The two worked together for the rest of Lynch's films.  Badalamenti's music was the perfect counterweight to Lynch, sometimes dreamy, sometimes jazzy, and often sinister like Pink Room from TWIN PEAKS: FIRE WALK WITH ME. Lastly, dejected after the critical and financial failure of DUNE, Lynch still had a deal to make another film for producer Dino de Laurentis. De Laurentis had a studio in Wilmington, North Carolina. Lynch had his BLUE VELVET script and de Laurentis and producer Richard Roth gave Lynch six million dollars and final cut. BLUE VELVET was critically acclaimed but not necessarily a financial success at first. Over time, BLUE VELVET became recognized as a classic and resurrect David Lynch's career. 

As strange and sometimes violent Lynch's movies were like BLUE VELVET, David Lynch was a sentimentalist at heart. Lynch took us on surreal journeys that most of the time culminated with a happy ending. With Lynch's passing, I don't see any filmmaker at this time that will pick up his mantle which is extremely sad. Lynch's legacy lives on thru his films and television shows. I hope at colleges around the United States, young students (like me and my classmates in 1986) will have a chance to view David Lynch's works and open their eyes to a hidden world they never knew existed. "It's a strange world, isn't it?" Jeffrey Beaumont says.  Yes it is Jeffrey.  Yes it is. 

The Ladykillers (1955)

Rarely in their careers did the Coen Brothers (Joel and Ethan) have a misfire. From their first film the low budget, neo noir BLOOD SIMPLE (1984) to their Academy Award winning NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN (2007) based on the Cormac McCarthy novel, the Coen Brothers films were unique, mesmerizing, and well crafted. The Coens weren't afraid to remake a classic film either. They set their eyes on Henry Hathaway's western TRUE GRIT (1969) starring John Wayne in his Oscar winning performance as Sheriff Rooster Cogburn. The Coen's TRUE GRIT (2010) with Jeff Bridges as the eye patch wearing Cogburn and co-starring Matt Damon and Hailee Stanfield added some scenes from the novel by Charles Portis that weren't in the original film but stayed fairly faithful to the original movie. The Coen's TRUE GRIT was praised as a modern classic of a previous classic, a far cry from the brothers first attempt at their remake of the British crime caper comedy THE LADYKILLERS (2004), based on Alexander Mackendrick's original THE LADYKILLERS (1955). 

Mackendrick's THE LADYKILLERS was one of the last and best British comedies that emerged from Ealing Studio that also included Charles Crichton's THE LAVENDER HILL MOB (1951). Many of the best Ealing Studio comedies starred Alec Guinness who appears in THE LADYKILLERS.  I have not seen the Coen Brothers version of THE LADYKILLERS (which stars Tom Hanks in the the Guinness role) and will probably watch it during my review of the original THE LADYKILLERS. Mackendrick's THE LADYKILLERS reputation proceeds itself.  Besides Guinness, THE LADYKILLERS also boasts two of my favorite British comedy actors Peter Sellers and Herbert Lom. Both were just starting out in films in the 1950s but would later reunite for the PINK PANTHER films for director Blake Edwards in the 60s and 70s.

I would surmise that the Coen Brothers were probably fans of the original THE LADYKILLERS and its underappreciated director with the strange last name Mackendrick. Alexander Mackendrick was born in the United States but moved to his native Scotland shortly after. Most of Mackendrick's success was at Ealing Studios where he made five films including THE MAN IN THE WHITE SUIT (1951) with Alec Guinness and his best known Ealing film THE LADYKILLERS. The Coens may have been drawn to remaking THE LADYKILLERS as Mackendrick's comedies had a darker edge to them than the typical British comedies of the era which tended to be more lighthearted. The Coens were no strangers to their own black comedies like THE BIG LEBOWSKI (1998) and BURN AFTER READING (2008). The success of THE LADYKILLERS would capture the attention of Hollywood who would bring Mackendrick back to the United States for his next film SWEET SMELL OF SUCCESS (1957) starring Burt Lancaster and Tony Curtis.  Mackendrick would discover that success would be a double-edged sword. 

With an original screenplay by William Rose (IT'S A MAD, MAD, MAD, MAD WORLD) and directed by Alexander Mackendrick, THE LADYKILLERS begins by introducing us to Mrs. Louisa Wilberforce (Katie Johnson), a sweet, slightly dotty widow. Mrs. Wilberforce visits the local police to tell the Superintendent (Jack Warner) her neighbor was mistaken about alien beings she thought landed in her garden. The police officers politely dismiss her. Mrs. Wilberforce who lives in a crooked house at the end of a cul-de-sac on top of a train tunnel next to Kings Cross Railroad station has two rooms for rent. She's followed home by a tall, thin menacing figure who turns out to be Professor Marcus (Alec Guinness).  Marcus is looking for two rooms to rent so he and his fellow musicians string quartet can rehearse. 

Only Marcus and his friends aren't really musicians. They're criminals planning an armored wagon robbery delivering $60,000 pounds to the Kings Cross railroad station.  Marcus's oddball crew includes the jittery and disgraced Major Claude Courtney (Cecil Parker), the menacing Louis Harvey (Herbert Lom), the empty headed muscle One-Round (Danny Green), and the overconfident Cockney Harry Robinson (Peter Sellers). As Marcus and the gang plot their robbery, Mrs. Wilberforce unintentionally becomes a nuisance, disturbing their planning with offers of tea or to needing help to catch her mischievous parrot General Gordon.  But Professor Marcus has a use for Mrs. Wilberforce. She will unwittingly help them bring the stolen money back to her house so the men can divide the loot.

Creating a perfect diversion, the armored wagon robbery goes off without a hitch. The money is transferred from smaller cases into a large trunk. Driving a fake taxi, Robinson drops the trunk off at the train station where it's placed in the parcels section. Mrs. Wilberforce arrives by taxi at the train station and picks up the trunk for Professor Marcus. She departs the train station to the gang's relief only to return moments later.  Mrs. Wilberforce forgot her umbrella. The gang follows Mrs. Wilberforce's taxi as it works its way to her home. Mrs. Wilberforce sees the Barrow Boy (Frankie Howerd) abusing a horse for eating apples off his cart. Mrs. Wilberforce forces the Taxi Driver (Kenneth Connor) to stop and comes to the horse's rescue to the horror of Marcus and his conspirators. Mrs. Wilberforce, the Barrow Boy, the Taxi Driver, and the large trunk end up at the police station. After the scuffle is cleared up, two police officers bring Mrs. Wilberforce and the large trunk to her home. Marcus and his thieves show up for their final rehearsal. The money is divided up and each criminal places his share in their musical instrument case. The men bid adieu to Mrs. Wilberforce. Marcus and his men have pulled off the perfect crime until One-Round catches his cello case in Mrs. Wilberforce's door. One-Round tugs at the case, ripping it open, his share of the loot spilling out onto the sidewalk in full view of Mrs. Wilberforce.

Marcus and the gang return to the house to try to explain why One-Round's cello case contains loads of cash and no cello.  But before they can explain, four gray-haired ladies show up for Mrs. Wilberforce's tea party. One of Mrs. Wilberforce's friends Lettice (Edie Martin) has the latest newspaper with headlines about the armored wagon robbery which catches Mrs. Wilberforce's attention. She insists the men stay for tea with her friends.  After the tea party ends, Marcus admits to her they did steal the money but that there's no sense in returning it. Insurance has already covered the loss for all parties. Marcus tells her she'll be arrested with them if she goes to the police. With all the excitement, Mrs. Wilberforce falls asleep. Marcus and the gang decide they must kill Mrs. Wilberforce. But who will do it? Louis cuts up matchsticks. The Major draws the shortest lot.  He invites Mrs. Wilberforce upstairs to strangle her but chickens out and tries to flee with his share of the money out the second floor window. THE LADYKILLERS concludes with Marcus, Claude, One-Round, Louis, and Harry turning on each other in dark fashion leaving Mrs. Wilberforce to confess to the police she has the stolen money. But will the authorities believe her and where are the criminals who stole it?

What makes THE LADYKILLERS a comedy classic is the combination of smart plotting and writing, excellent directing, and perfect casting. Mackendrick and Rose set up the ending of the film in the first scene when the local police politely dismiss Mrs. Wilberforce's explanation of her neighbor believing aliens were in her garden. We don't realize it yet (and Marcus and his gang will never know it) but the authorities will never believe anything that Mrs. Wilberforce will tell them going forward including that she has the stolen sixty thousand pounds in her home. The introduction of each criminal is done simply with each character walking up and framed in the doorway as Marcus introduces them to us and Mrs. Wilberforce. Each criminal is distinct. Marcus with his protruding front teeth (resembling actor Alistair Sim but more on that later). The hulking One-Round. Major Claude and his thick moustache. Harry with his pompadour hair.  And the fedora wearing Louis. Even Mrs. Wilberforce stands out with her rosy cheeks, expressive blue eyes, and pink dresses. 

Color plays a big part in THE LADYKILLERS. In fact, THE LADYKILLERS is the only comedy in the Ealing Studios canon made in color. It might be a black comedy but the film is full of deep, saturated colors. The two rooms that Professor Marcus rents from Mrs. Wilberforce are a garish green and bright red. The green room symbolizes the thieves greed and vice as they plot their robbery of the armored wagon. The red room foreshadows the deaths that will occur as the gang contemplates murdering Mrs. Wilberforce before turning on one another. Mrs. Wilberforce's pink outfit represents purity amongst all these shady criminals dressed in mostly black and gray suits.

Production design plays an important role in THE LADYKILLERS. Mrs. Wilberforce's house is the perfect (if unsound) structure for Professor Wilburn and his cohorts. The pictures don't hang straight. The staircase to the second floor leans one way. The house is crooked like the men who have moved in temporarily. Film historians point out that Mrs. Wilberforce's home represents the end of the British Empire with its Victorian decor. Pictures of 19th century debutantes, bucolic forests, and Mrs. Wilberforce's deceased sea captain husband adorn the first floor and along the staircase. Her home is the last bastion of the once great, powerful British Empire. 

Even with the great Alec Guinness and the first major film role for Peter Sellers, sweet little old Katie Johnson shines in THE LADYKILLERS.  Johnson's Mrs. Wilberforce is literally a force of nature in the film, blissfully unaware of her superpowers besides honesty. As Professor Marcus laments, "It was a great plan, except for the Human Element. So many plans fail to take into account the Human Element. Mrs. Wilberforce will always be with us. A whole army couldn't take her out." Like many great robbery films from John Huston's THE ASPHALT JUNGLE (1951) to Michael Mann's HEAT (1995), the Human Element ruined those robberies as well. But those films didn't have a sweet, innocent old lady blow up their intricate scheme. We are warned at the very start of THE LADYKILLERS that Mrs. Wilberforce will be a thorn in the criminals side when she causes a baby in a pram to cry for no reason. THE LADYKILLERS would be Katie Johnson's crowning achievement.  The 76 year old actress would win a BAFTA (British Academy Award) for her performance as Mrs. Wilberforce, appear in one more film HOW TO MURDER A RICH UNCLE (1957), and pass away that same year at the age of 78, two years after THE LADYKILLERS release.

When Alec Guinness was offered the role of the ringleader Professor Marcus for THE LADYKILLERS, he told director Mackendrick that fellow English actor Alistair Sim (STAGE FRIGHT, A CHRISTMAS CAROL) was born to play the role. Mackendrick informed Guinness that Sim had been offered the part but was unavailable.  The chameleon Guinness (perhaps as a homage) would transform himself into resembling Sim complete with buck teeth and wispy, blondish hair.  It is another of Guinness's finest comedic performances. Professor Marcus is the brains behind the robbery plot. He and his co-conspirators pull of his master plan only to watch it unravel at the hands of the kindly, unassuming Mrs. Wilberforce. Looking over Guinness's filmography, he was the top comedic actor in the 1950s until Ealing Studios quit making comedies at the end of the decade. Guinness would easily slide into drama, becoming David Lean's good luck charm from THE BRIDGE OVER RIVER KWAI (1957) to DR. ZHIVAGO (1965). Mostly working in British television in the 1970s, George Lucas would introduce Alec Guinness to a new generation of fans as Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi in STAR WARS (1977). 

Although Herbert Lom and Peter Sellers would become famous for their roles as the suffering turned psychotic Chief Inspector Charles Dreyfus and bumbling Inspector Jacques Cousteau respectively in THE PINK PANTHER films, Lom and Sellers were just starting out in film when they appeared in THE LADYKILLERS. Lom started out playing exotic supporting characters in films like Henry Hathaway's THE BLACK ROSE (1950). Lom was performing as the King of Siam in the London stage production of The King and I and his head was mostly shaven during the filming of THE LADYKILLERS. Lom wears a fedora for most of the film to hide that fact. Lom's Louis is the most cold-hearted, ruthless member of the five. Yet, even Louis and all his menace can't overcome the indomitably kind Mrs. Wilberforce.

For Sellers, THE LADYKILLERS was his first meaningful film having worked primarily on the BBC Radio Show The Goon Show. Sellers shows glimpses of his future expertise in comic pratfalls and mishaps in THE LADYKILLERS especially when he volunteers to catch Mrs. Wilberforce's parrot. His skill at accents make him perfect as the Cockney speaking hood Harry Robinson. Alec Guinness was Sellers idol and working with Guinness on THE LADYKILLERS would rub off on Sellers. Guinness had played eight roles in Robert Hamer's KIND HEARTS AND CORONETS (1949). Sellers would soon play multiple roles himself in both Jack Arnold's THE MOUSE THAT ROARED (1957) and more famously in Stanley Kubrick's DR. STRANGELOVE (1964). 

When I first heard Cecil Parker speak in THE LADYKILLERS, I knew exactly where I had heard Parker before. Parker played the philandering, isolationist loving Mr. Todhunter in Alfred Hitchcock's train thriller THE LADY VANISHES (1938).  He was an unlikable character who got his just desserts at the film's end, waving a white handkerchief  and still getting shot and I couldn't forget him. In THE LADYKILLERS, dressed in a yellow suit and with his white moustache, Parker's Major Claude looks like the prototype for Colonel Mustard from the Clue board game. The Major is some kind of disgraced military officer, fallen on hard times. If it wasn't for Mrs. Wilberforce, the nervous Major would probably have been the Human Element to ruin the perfect crime. Instead, he's the first one to turn on the group and the Major pays the price.

The filmmakers don't give Danny Green's towering, lumbering character One-Round any back story in THE LADYKILLERS but his name tells it all. He must have been a boxer who either knocked his opponent out in the first round or he took a dive versus his heavyweight opponent in the first round per a gambler or mobster's orders. As imposing as Green's One-Round is, he's a kitten around Mrs. Wilberforce. Other credits for Green include Nathan Juran's THE 7TH VOYAGE OF SINBAD (1958) and William Castle's remake of  THE OLD DARK HOUSE (1963).

CRAZYFILMGUY made a last second effort and viewed the Coen Brothers remake of THE LADYKILLERS. Although many English movies and television shows have successfully been reworked into American movies and television shows, the Coen Brothers version is not one of those successes. Yes, the Coens made some interesting choices, moving the location of THE LADYKILLERS from London to Mississippi; changing the pleasant English Mrs. Wilberforce into the bible thumping widow Marva Munson (Irma P. Hall); and the heist from an armored wagon holdup near King's Cross to plucking $1.6 million from a riverboat casino. What the Coen Brothers remake proves is that THE LADYKILLERS belongs in England.  It's an English comedy with unique English characters that just doesn't Americanize. The Coens dumb up most of the criminals (easier for American audiences to recognize), throw in heaps of profanity, and make their THE LADYKILLERS the opposite of Mackendrick's sophisticated gem. 

For director Alexander Mackendrick, THE LADYKILLERS would be his calling card to Hollywood where Burt Lancaster would hire him to direct the savage SWEET SMELL OF SUCCESS (1957) written by playwright Clifford Odets and Ernest Lehman based on Lehman's novel. Today, SWEET SMELL OF SUCCESS is considered a masterpiece.  For audiences in the 1950s, the film's blistering take on a gossip columnist who rules New York and the soulless press agent who tries to appease him was too much for audiences. SWEET SMELL OF SUCCESS would be a critical and box office failure at the time. Mackendrick would only make a couple more films before he was offered the job as Dean of the Film Department of the California Institute of the Arts where he was beloved by film students from 1969 until his death in 1993.

When you watch a heist film, you often find yourself rooting for the criminals to get away with the crime. In THE LADYKILLERS, I was rooting for Professor Marcus and his odd accomplices. They had pulled off the perfect crime, they weren't going to hurt Mrs. Wilberforce, and they were just waiting for One-Round to say goodbye.  But heist films almost never end happily. THE LADYKILLERS even tosses a red herring when Mrs. Wilberforce slumps in her sitting chair as if she's expired only to awaken from a quick nap. The criminals have multiple opportunities to just flee and take their chances that the police won't believe her story (which turns out to be true).  But poor judgement will cloud their thinking and they decide to kill Mrs. Wilberforce to silence her with unexpected consequences for them all. 

Like some American comedies, some English comedies from the past are lowbrow, reaching to the wider public with stale, familiar stories and going for cheap laughs.  The British Ealing Studios raised the comedy bar with its series of original stories using a troupe of excellent English actors to delight audiences. THE LADYKILLERS was Ealing's crowning achievement in the 1950s, starring its best comedic actor Alec Guinness (surrounded with a hilarious group of supporting players) and its best director Alexander Mackendrick, all shot in glorious, deep color. Even one of America's best pair of directors couldn't improve on THE LADYKILLERS.  Make yourself a cup of tea, settle into your soft recliner and prepare yourself for 91 minutes of dark, comedic glee. 

White Heat (1949)

My first encounter with the actor James Cagney wasn't from any of his over 60 films. It was from comedian Rich Little in the 1970s who would come on THE TONIGHT SHOW WITH JOHNNY CARSON and do impressions of famous people and politicians. Little did a great impression of James Cagney ("You dirty rat!") that imprinted on me to this day. I may never have seen Cagney yet but I sure knew what he sounded like. Cagney would often show up in caricature in Warner Brothers cartoons I watched either as himself or impersonated by Bugs Bunny.  Along with Errol Flynn, Humphrey Bogart, and Bette Davis, James Cagney was one of the biggest stars for Warner Brothers in the 1930s and 40s. I gravitated first toward Flynn for his swashbuckling films like CAPTAIN BLOOD (1935) and THE ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD (1938) and toward Bogart for THE MALTESE FALCON (1941) and CASABLANCA (1943).  Cagney was appearing mostly in gangster films like William Wellman's THE PUBLIC ENEMY (1931) and Michael Curtiz's ANGELS WITH DIRTY FACES (1938). I wasn't particularly interested in gangsters early in my movie watching youth.  That would change with Francis Coppola's THE GODFATHER (1973) and Martin Scorsese's GOODFELLAS (1991). 

I recently watched Raoul Walsh's THE ROARING TWENTIES (1939) with Cagney and Humphrey Bogart in which Cagney actually played a relatively nice, naive World War I veteran who becomes a successful bootlegger during Prohibition until his partner Bogart turns on him.  For the most part, when Cagney did play gangsters or criminals they were charismatic but ultimately bad guys (like Bogart in THE ROARING TWENTIES). One of Cagney's final bad guy films is one of his most famous and over the top performances as criminal Cody Jarrett, a psychopath with a mother complex in the great Raoul Walsh's WHITE  HEAT (1949). 

By 1949, Cagney had been making movies since the beginning of the talkies in the early 30s. In WHITE HEAT, Cagney finally looks older and paunchier yet Cagney's just as dynamic as when he was hoofing it as George M. Cohan in Michael Curtiz's YANKEE DOODLE DANDY (1942). Besides Cagney, WHITE HEAT has the good fortune of having Warner Brothers stalwart Raoul Walsh at the helm as director. Walsh is not as famous as well known Warner directors Michael Curtiz (DODGE CITY) or John Huston (THE TREASURE OF SIERRA MADRE). Walsh was just as prolific and his movies had great stories, complex characters, and plenty of action in films like HIGH SIERRA (1940) and THEY DIED WITH THEIR BOOTS ON (1941).

With a screenplay by Ivan Goff and Ben Roberts suggested by a story by Virginia Kellogg and directed by the eye patch wearing Raoul Walsh, WHITE HEAT begins on the California State Line where criminal Cody Jarrett (James Cagney) and his gang including Big Ed Somers (Steve Cochran) and Cotton Valletti (Wally Cassell) rob a train carrying $300,000 in federal currency. A couple of innocent train engineers are shot and killed and one of Cody's gang Zuckie Hommell (Ford Rainey) catches a blast of hot steam in the face from the locomotive. Cody and his gang return to their high sierra hideout where they hook up with his mother Ma Jarrett (Margaret Wycherly) and wife and moll Verna Jarrett (Virginia Mayo). There's some tension between Cody, Big Ed, and Verna. Cody suddenly has a seizure. Ma takes Cody to another room and helps him overcome his migraine. A storm arrives, providing the perfect getaway for Jarrett's gang. They leave behind the bandaged Zuckie who freezes to death in the cabin. After making a death mask of Zuckie's face, Treasury Agent Philip Evans (John Archer) is able to connect the dead man to Cody's gang and the train heist. 

The Jarrett Gang returns to a small southwest city, hiding out in a non-descript motel off the beaten track. Returning from the market where she bought strawberries for her son, Ma Jarrett is tailed by several members of Evans task force. She almost loses them. Evans accidentally finds her car. Waiting for back up, he encounters Cody who wounds Evans in the shoulder. Cody, Ma, and Verna flee, hiding out at a Drive-In theater.  Cody reveals to Ma and Verna his latest plan. He's going to turn himself in to the authorities, only for a heist in Springfield, Illinois that another crook committed that had no murders. Cody made a deal with that crook to take the fall for that crime to avoid the death penalty for the train heist killings. Cody is sent to a federal prison in Illinois. Evans brings in his undercover prison specialist Hank Fallon (Edmond O'Brien). Hank under the fake name Vic Pardo will be placed in the prison to ingratiate himself with Cody and find out who bank rolled the train robbery.

Cody goes to prison for a sentence of 1-3 years. With Cody behind bars, Big Ed takes over the Jarrett gang, under the suspicious eye of Ma Jarrett. Hank works to get into Cody's confidence.  While standing in line to be vaccinated, Hank recognizes a convict who he sent to prison. Hank starts a fight to avoid getting identified. Big Ed pulls off a heist, netting $57,000.  Ma reminds Big Ed that Cody still receives a share.  Big Ed confides to Verna he has an inside man named Roy Parker (Paul Guilfoyle) who will kill Cody for Big Ed. Roy tries to drop an engine on Cody. Hank notices and pushes Cody out of the way just in time. Ma visits Cody in prison and tells him Big Ed and Verna are now an item. Cody begins a plan to break out of prison. Hank offers to help. Cody asks a new prisoner Tommy Ryley (Robert Osterloh) if he's heard any news about Ma.  Tommy tells him that Ma is dead. Cody has a breakdown. He's put in a straightjacket and prepared to be sent to an asylum per the prison physician Dr. Harris's diagnosis.

Before Cody can be whisked away, Tommy smuggles in a gun to Cody. Cody, Hank, Parker, Tommy, and the Reader (Michael Curtin) force Dr. Harris to drive them out of the penitentiary and to freedom. Cody locates Big Ed and Verna at their latest hideout. Verna gives up Big Ed to Cody who shoots him. Cody and Verna are back together. Cody meets with the Trader aka Winston (Fred Clark) who plans and bankrolls their next job - to steal almost half a million from a chemical plant's payroll. Cody suggests the old Trojan Horse ploy. They will buy an empty gas tanker that will be driven by ex-con Bo Creel (Ian MacDonald) who's a driver at the plant and hide themselves in it until they pass through the security gate. Hank plants a homing device under the tanker for Evans and his T-Men to track the tanker. WHITE HEAT'S explosive finale has shoot-outs, tear gas, double crosses, and Cody atop a chemical holding sphere, fire all around him, shouting his final famous line, "Made it Ma! Top of the World!"  

WHITE HEAT'S Cody Jarrett may be one of the most complex, fascinating criminal characters in the Golden Age of Cinema. Nobody could have played Cody better than James Cagney. Cody is a homicidal, psychopathic criminal but he's so much more. Cody's a Mama's boy, propped up when he's depressed by his mother Ma Jarrett who's one of the gang. Cody depends on Ma more than a grown man normally would. When Cody has his debilitating headaches, it's Ma who escorts him to another room and cares for him, shielding his weakness from his fellow crooks. WHITE HEAT hints that insanity and psychological issues runs in the Jarrett family, beginning with Cody's father. Cody had a tough childhood and had to fight most of his life to get near the top of criminal food chain. His mother was there to support him all the way. 

Which brings us to Cody Jarrett's famous phrase, "Top of the World!" Top of the world represents Cody both figuratively and literally. When Cody's feeling strong and in control, he'll use that phrase. It's a feeling instilled by his mother Ma who has pushed Cody from a young age to strive to be the best, even if it's the criminal best. With Cagney's short stature, the phrase is a mantra for short guy Cody. He can't be tall in stature but he can be at the top of the criminal food chain. Cody often references his mother when saying it. After Ma's murdered and Cody escapes from prison, he grows sullen at her absence. He walks into the woods and has a chat with his dead mother (off screen). Cody returns to the safe house revitalized. Ma's spirit has put Cody on top again. In WHITE HEAT'S fiery finale, Cody climbs to the highest point at the chemical plant as his life of crime comes to an end. Before sharp shooter Hank/Vic fires one last fatal shot at Cody, Cody shouts his final words to the world and to the one person who believed in him the most. "Look at me Ma! Top of the World!," Cody exclaims before the holding sphere explodes in a ball of fire, obliterating Cody forever. 

If you're a fan of geometric shapes, WHITE HEAT is full of fascinating triangles, relationship triangles. First, there's the Cody, Verna, Ma triangle.  Cody and Verna seem to have a love/hate relationship. Having Cody's mother Ma in the gang and always around them probably doesn't help.  Verna feels Ma is always looking over her shoulder, keeping a watchful eye on her, judging the woman who has a place in her son's cold heart. It's to no one's surprise that when Cody's sent to prison and Big Ed and Verna start to get a little cozier, Ma tattles on them to Cody. Big Ed and Verna's answer to Ma snooping on them will be Verna shooting and killing Ma (off screen and revealed later).

The Cody, Verna, Big Ed triangle adds nice tension to the story. Cody's the jealous type but Big Ed plays it cool with his hot headed boss.  Verna just wants to be on the right side of the two alpha males. As bloodthirsty as Cody and Big Ed are killing innocent bystanders in their crime sprees, Verna rivals them.  She murders Ma Jarrett to get her out of the way. When Cody comes looking for Big Ed and Verna, Verna turns on Big Ed, setting him up for Cody to gun him down.  The Cody/Verna relationship is back on. There's no code of honor among these thieves. 

The relationship between Cody and Hank/Vic in WHITE HEAT is classic criminal bonding with a catch. Hank/Vic is an undercover treasury agent, planted in the same prison as Cody so he can infiltrate Cody's inner circle and if he's lucky, befriend the maniac and uncover who Cody's silent partner for funding his holdups. Cody's suspicious of everyone when he first arrives in the pen. Hank/Vic begins to win Cody over after saving his life from a falling engine. When Cody breaks out of prison with Hank/Vic and his cronies and reuniting with Verna, Hank offers to fix her broken radio, further ingratiating himself with Cody. Even though Hank/Vic is risking his neck both in prison (where he's almost recognized by a convict he put away years earlier) and running with the dangerous Jarrett Gang, Hank begins to develop a friendship with Cody.  It's a friendship doomed to survive. Director Quentin Tarantino will use this similar plot twist in RESERVOIR DOGS (1992) with undercover cop Tim Roth as Mr. Orange bonding with one of his fellow crooks Harvey Keitel as Mr. White when they are both hired for a jewelry store heist that goes terribly awry. 

James Cagney, the golden boy of Warner Brothers in the 1930s, grew weary of playing gangsters and criminals for the studio.  After appearing in YANKEE DOODLE DANDY, Cagney would leave Warner Brothers to pursue other types of roles in different genres, forming his own production company for films like JOHNNY COME LATELY (1943) and BLOOD ON THE SUN (1945). Cagney would eventually be drawn back to Warners for WHITE HEAT.  Cagney reportedly found the WHITE HEAT script dull so he suggested giving Cody a domineering mother similar to the real life bank robber Ma Barker with her sons. The intense relationship between Cody and Ma is the crux of WHITE HEAT. Cagney goes so far as having Cody sit on Ma's lap in one scene (which both Cagney and Walsh took credit for the idea).

I recently came across actress Virginia Mayo in Raoul Walsh's western remake of his own HIGH SIERRA called COLORADO TERRITORY (1949) where she stood out. Mayo was just one of a group of interesting actresses during that time including Jane Greer, Veronica Lake, and Jane Russell. The underrated Mayo stands out as she wasn't typecast just as a femme fatale. Mayo was a dance hall girl in COLORADO TERRITORY, an unfaithful wife to a returning WWII vet in William Wyler's THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES (1945), and Burt Lancaster's captive and love interest in Jacques Tourneur swashbuckling THE FLAME AND THE ARROW (1950). In WHITE HEAT, Mayo bares her femme fatale fangs as Cody's scheming wife Verna. Verna's always trying to find the most advantageous side to be on whether it's Cody, Big Ed, or at the end of the film the T-Men (they turn her down to make a deal). In the mid-70s, I was on a Universal Studio's tour in Los Angeles. We stopped at a stop sign on the studio lot. Our tour guide pointed out an older, pretty woman sitting on a bench. "That's screen star  Virginia Mayo," he said. I have a feeling Universal hired retired movie stars like Mayo to spice up the tour. Sadly, at the time, I had no idea who Mayo was. Now I do. 

The versatile and prolific Edmond O'Brien pops up again, this time in WHITE HEAT as Hank Fallon, the Treasury Department's undercover snoop placed in prison under the pseudonym Vic Pardo to buddy up to Cody Jarrett. O'Brien's Hank/Vic's has a cool demeanor, patiently biding his time until he can get in Cody's good graces while navigating the danger of someone recognizing he's a law officer or getting ratted out to Cody.  Like Virginia Mayo, O'Brien was rarely typecast. O'Brien would play a Roman senator in Joseph L. Mankiewicz's JULIUS CAESAR (1953), win the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor as Ava Gardner's publicist Oscar Muldoon in Mankiewicz's THE BAREFOOT CONTESSA (1954) with Humphrey Bogart and Ava Gardner, and play a newspaper editor in John Ford's western THE MAN WHO SHOT LIBERTY VALANCE (1962) with John Wayne and James Stewart. 

Margaret Wycherly was no stranger to playing mothers in film, most notably as Gary Cooper's Mother York in Howard Hawks SERGEANT YORK (1941) where she was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. Wycherly's Ma Jarrett is much darker and sinister than Ma York. She's built up her damaged son into a criminal powerhouse. When Cody's sent to prison, Ma loses her leverage in the gang. She's ultimately murdered by her daughter-in-law Verna for spying on her while Cody was in prison. And look for Native American Olympian and football athlete Jim Thorpe as Big Convict sitting near Cagney at a prison lunch table. 

Raoul Walsh began directing in the silent era, starting out as an assistant director on D.W. Griffith's THE BIRTH OF A NATION (1915) before turning to directing himself including the original THE THIEF OF BAGDAD (1924). Walsh would famously wear an eye patch over his right eye for most of his career after a jack rabbit crashed through his windshield. Like Michael Curtiz, Walsh was comfortable in all film genres including crime drama, film noir, westerns, romantic comedy, and adventure.  Walsh would hit his peak at Warner Brothers in a three year period from 1931 to 1941 with hits like THE ROARING TWENTIES, HIGH SIERRA, and THE STRAWBERRY BLONDE (1941). I think Walsh's best films for Warner Brothers were with Cagney and Bogart. In the 1940s, Walsh would direct several World War II themed films with Errol Flynn including DESPERATE JOURNEY (1942) co-starring Ronald Reagan and OBJECTIVE, BURMA! (1945). 

WHITE HEAT is a pretty ordinary heist film that has great performances from Cagney, Mayo, O'Brien, and Wycherly. What makes WHITE HEAT special is the intense family relationship between Cody Jarrett and his mother Ma Jarrett. Normally, a mother/son bonding wouldn't make anyone blink an eye. But the fact that Cody and Ma are members of a murderous criminal gang makes this family dynamic special. Add in the great, underappreciated Raoul Walsh at the helm, WHITE HEAT is Cagney's swan song to the movies that made him a star but also drove him to seek out different roles. 

The Santa Clause (1994)

Only a few times in my film/television viewing lifetime have I had lapses where I wasn't aware of the release or premiere of a new movie or television show. When I backpacked for two months in Europe after college in 1987, I lost track of films that came out in theaters between October and December of that year. When I worked in the film industry in the early 90s, I was working 16-18 hour days and didn't have time to watch television at night. I had no recollection of TV shows like ST. ELSEWHERE, THE WEST WING, or L.A. LAW. And when my son was born in 1994, I was consumed with learning to be a new father and missed the release of a charming holiday film two months after his birth in November called THE SANTA CLAUSE.  

It wasn't until November 1995 of the following year when my wife, one year old son, and I traveled to New Jersey to celebrate Thanksgiving with my wife's aunt that I discovered the magic of THE SANTA CLAUSE. We were trying to stay awake after a filling turkey dinner. Aunt Karin asked if we wanted to watch a movie. She pulled out a VHS tape, popped it into the VHS player and for the next one hour and 37 minutes, we were captivated by this clever holiday film starring rising stand up comedian turned television sitcom star turned movie actor Tim Allen. 

Stand up comics have been successful moving from comedy clubs to television shows. Comedians like Roseanne Barr, Eddie Murphy, Robin Williams, and Tim Allen all made the transition and had hit television shows. The tougher part is going from television to feature films. Robin Williams first attempt was George Roy Hill's THE WORLD ACCORDING TO GARP (1983) based on the John Irving novel. Williams played against type from his crazier TV space alien character Mork from MORK AND MINDY (1978-1982). Audiences didn't swarm to see Williams as a regular guy. Wild and Crazy Guy Steve Martin tried out his irreverent humor on the big screen in Carl Reiner's THE JERK (1979). Martin had a niche following as a comedian but THE JERK didn't appeal to the masses. Both Williams and Martin would eventually find the right projects and become major film stars. For Tim Allen who played blue collar DIY television show host  Tim "the Tool Man" Taylor on TVs HOME IMPROVEMENT (1991-1999), his leap to film playing a white collar toy salesman who by accident becomes the next St. Nick in THE SANTA CLAUSE was a smart, safe career move.

With an original screenplay by Leo Benvenuti and Steve Rudnick and directed by John Pasquin, THE SANTA CLAUSE begins at (where else?) a company Christmas party where Scott Calvin (Tim Allen) and his co-worker Susan (Judith Scott) are acknowledged by their toy company boss Mr. Whittle (Peter Boyle) as the top marketing team for the year. Recently divorced, Scott hustles to his ex-wife Laura (Wendy Crewson) and new husband Dr. Neal Miller (Judge Reinhold) house to pick up his son Charlie Calvin (Eric Lloyd) on Christmas Eve. Neither Scott nor Charlie are exactly in the Christmas spirit. Scott burns the turkey dinner and he and Charlie end up eating out at a Denny's filled with other divorced Dads and their kids. After reading The Night Before Christmas to Charlie before bed, Charlie asks if Scott believes in Santa Claus. Scott patronizes Charlie and tells him he's positive that a man in a red suit lives in the North Pole and flies a sleigh driven by eight reindeer.

That night, Charlie's awakened by a clatter outside. He wakes up Scott who also hears the noise. They go out front to investigate.  Scott sees a man in a red suit on his roof and shouts out to him accidentally scaring the stranger. The stranger falls off the roof onto a pile of snow. Charlie tells his Dad he's killed Santa Claus. Scott finds a card in the red suit that simply states SANTA CLAUS, NORTH POLE.  On the back of the card it says "If something should happen to me, put on the suit. The reindeer will know what to do." Santa's body disappears, leaving just the suit.  A ladder materializes. Charlie climbs up it and Scott grabs the suit and follows Charlie to the roof where a sleigh filled with toys and eight reindeer led by Comet await them. Scott and Charlie climb into the sleigh and it takes off into the night sky where Scott (after putting on the Santa suit) delivers toys all over the world. Afterward, the reindeer bring Scott and Charlie to the North Pole where they meet Bernard (David Krumholtz), the head elf of Santa's Workshop. 

Bernard gives Scott and Charlie a tour of Santa's North Pole operations and presents Charlie with a snow globe. They meet other elves including Elf-Judy (Paige Tamada). Scott just wants to go home.  Bernard informs Scott that since he read the card and put on Santa's suit, he has accepted the Santa Clause (printed in very small type on the card). Scott has 11 months to get his affairs in order before the next Christmas. Scott awakens the next morning in his own bed, dressed in satin red pajamas from the North Pole. Laura picks up Charlie on Christmas morning. Scott can't explain the crazy night before.  At a Bring Your Dad to Work Day at school, Charlie brags that his Dad is Santa Claus. Laura and Neal begin to worry about Charlie's obsession with Scott as Santa Claus. Scott wakes up one morning with white hair and a white beard. He's also put on some weight. Laura and Neal begin to freak out about Scott's transformation into a Santa Claus like figure. Laura and Neal petition to have Scott's visitation rights to see Charlie taken away.  After talking to Charlie, Judge Whalen (Ron Hartmann) sides with Laura and Neal.

Scott says good bye to Charlie. He asks Laura for a moment alone with Charlie. Bernard the Elf shows up and whisks Scott and Charlie away to the North Pole. Laura reports Charlie's "kidnapping" to the local police who put out an APB on Scott/Santa. At the North Pole, Scott/Santa and the elves prepare Santa's sleigh for Christmas Eve. The reindeer fly Scott/Santa all over the world delivering gifts. They finally arrive at Laura and Neal's house where the police arrest Scott/Santa. The North Pole deploys an E.L.F.S rescue team to pick up Charlie from the roof and extract Scott/Santa from jail. Scott/Santa brings Charlie back to Laura and Neal. Scott/Santa tells Charlie he can't always be with him now that he's Santa Claus. Bernard tells Charlie that he just has to shake the snow globe he gave Charlie and Scott/Santa will appear right away. Scott/Santa gives Laura and Neal the gifts they never received as children. Laura burns the custody papers. The police surround Neal's house. Scott/Santa and the reindeer fly over them as he heads back to the North Pole and his new role.

With all its funny one liners and sense of holiday magic to it, THE SANTA CLAUSE spotlights a serious domestic fact for a holiday film: families separated during Christmas due to divorce. Scott and Laura are newly divorced and the collateral damage is their son Charlie. THE SANTA CLAUSE begins with Scott having to pick up Charlie from his ex-wife on Christmas Eve night. Irritated with this new situation, Scott has lost the Christmas spirit and takes out his frustration on Charlie as they clash over the rules of Christmas. In THE SANTA CLAUSE'S most devastating scene, Scott and Charlie have Christmas Eve dinner at Denny's. Scott gazes around and sees several other single Dad's with their children, no mother in sight. Divorce can be a Scrooge during the holidays.

Although Charlie's parents are divorced, he's the one beacon who hasn't lost the spirit of Christmas, its traditions and legends. It's the adults like Scott, Laura, and Neal who are the unbelievers. Charlie's loyalty is rewarded when he and Scott end up in Santa's sleigh and a trip to the North Pole after a fluke accident to Santa at Scott's house. After discovering that Santa, his elves, and flying reindeer are real, Charlie's enthusiasm for all things Santa begins to frighten his mother and new husband Neal. When Scott begins to turn into the actual Santa Claus, Laura and Neal blame Scott for Charlie's Christmas zealousness, resulting in Scott losing his visitation rights to Charlie. Once again, the grown ups just won't believe. Thankfully for Charlie (and the audience), the elves will arrive to save the night.

Fortunately, THE SANTA CLAUSE is 99% fun. The film makes an interesting choice that works, casting child actors instead of little people to play the elves. Scott's interaction with the elf children is hilarious with some of the funniest lines in the film delivered at the North Pole between Scott and the elves. When Elf-Judy tells Scott she's 1200 years old, Scott tells he she looks pretty good for someone that age. Judy replies, "Thank, but I'm seeing someone in wrapping." My favorite line is when a clueless Scott first delivers toys to children after putting on the Santa suit. He comes across a young girl sleeping on a couch next to her Christmas tree. She's not impressed with Scott's appearance. When Scott prepares to fly back up the chimney, she reminds him that he didn't drink the glass of milk put out for Santa.  Scott retorts, "I'm lactose intolerant!" 

THE SANTA CLAUSE has fun playing with the Christmas norms that we are familiar with. The filmmakers have the North Pole become a James Bond like hideout. Santa's sleigh lands on a platform that descends to the subterranean Workshop. Elf-Quentin channels Bond's gadget master Q, explaining to Scott all the different gadgets that Santa's sleigh contains. Later, when Scott/Santa is arrested and thrown into the slammer, an elf SWAT team is sent from the North Pole called E.L.F.S. (Effective Liberating Flight Squad) to liberate Scott/Santa, providing some humorous sequences as they tangle with the local police. 

With THE SANTA CLAUSE, Tim Allen was on a roll. According to IMDB, not only did Allen have the #1 television show with HOME IMPROVEMENT in 1994, he had the #1 non-fiction book on the New York Times Bestseller List with Don't Stand Too Close To a Naked Man and THE SANTA CLAUSE was #1 at the Box Office for its opening week. Scott Calvin (did you notice Scott's initials are the same as Santa Claus -- SC) is not a big departure from Allen's TV character on HOME IMPROVEMENT except he's in marketing for a toy company rather than a DIY TV host. A few times, Allen let's his TV character mannerisms slip out but Allen mostly plays a new character, a mild Scrooge like curmudgeon who transforms into the benevolent, red nosed St. Nick. Allen was a now a bona fide star and his winning streak would continue with successful THE SANTA CLAUSE sequels including Michael Lembeck's THE SANTA CLAUSE 2 (2002) where Scott/Santa needs to find a Mrs. Claus (Elizabeth Mitchell) or else he will cease to be Santa; David Parisot's very funny sci-fi spoof GALAXY QUEST (1999) with Allen, Sigourney Weaver, and Alan Rickman; and John Lasseter's TOY STORY (1995) and its sequels which would forever endear audiences with Buzz Lightyear voiced by Allen.

The underrated Judge Reinhold once again nearly steals a film, this time in THE SANTA CLAUSE as Charlie's new step father Dr. Neal Miller. Neal is a psychiatrist who seemingly wants to analyze everyone he comes into contact with. Neal should be the villain of the film (he's now Laura's husband not Scott and he's trying to softly let Charlie know that Santa isn't real) but Reinhold makes Neal sympathetic and a little sad. Reinhold has been nailing his characters from teenager Brad Hamilton in Amy Heckerling's FAST TIMES AT RIDGEMONT HIGH (1982) to L.A. Detective Billy Rosewood in Martin Brest's BEVERLY HILLS COP (1984) and its sequels going toe to toe with Eddie Murphy. Reinhold would reprise Neal Miller in THE SANTA CLAUSE 2 and THE SANTA CLAUSE 3: THE ESCAPE CLAUSE (2006). 

The rest of the cast in THE SANTA CLAUSE play their parts to perfection. Canadian actress Wendy Crewson (AIR FORCE ONE) does a nice job as Scott's ex-wife Laura. She comes off as a caring mother trying to work out this new arrangement of raising and sharing her son Charlie with Scott now that they are divorced. The ex-wife role can often be one dimensional. Crewson gives Laura depth and compassion. Another tricky role is young Charlie. If the child actor isn't any good, it can come off as lame or annoying next to a comedian.  Eric Lloyd as Scott and Laura's son Charlie pulls it off. Charlie's transformation from not wanting to be with his father on Christmas Eve to idolizing Scott as the new Santa is the backbone of THE SANTA CLAUSE.  It reconnects Charlie with Scott. Lloyd would appear in all three THE SANTA CLAUSE films and Netflix's THE SANTA CLAUSES series (2022-23). 

Although most of the elves are young kids with pointy prosthetic elf ears in THE SANTA CLAUSE, David Krumholtz distinguishes himself as the taller and older head elf Bernard. Bernard cuts through Scott's sarcasm (he's probably dealt with a few new doubting Santas' in his long lifetime) and explains the clause that will forever change his Scott's life. Krumholtz would not be typecast by playing elves for the rest of his career (except THE SANTA CLAUSE sequels) and has worked with top directors including the Coen Brothers in THE BALLAD OF BUSTER SCRUGGS (2018) and Christopher Nolan in OPPENHEIMER (2023). Young Paige Tamada stands out as Elf-Judy who makes Scott cocoa and prepares him for his new role.  THE SANTA CLAUSE'S only glaring error is not utilizing the great Peter Boyle (YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN) to better effect as Scott's toy company boss Mr. Whittle. We only see Boyle in a couple of scenes. 

Director John Pasquin had worked with Tim Allen before THE SANTA CLAUSE, directing 39 episodes of Allen's HOME IMPROVEMENT. Pasquin mostly worked in television but would direct a few more feature films including another film with Allen called JUNGLE 2 JUNGLE (1997) co-starring Martin Short and MISS CONGENIALITY 2: ARMED AND DANGEROUS (2005) with Sandra Bullock and William Shatner. Pasquin is married to actress Jobeth Williams (POLTERGEIST). Disney took its time making a sequel (probably due to Allen becoming a bigger star). THE SANTA CLAUSE 2 would be worth waiting 8 years for, returning the original cast along with Elizabeth Mitchell as Scott's new love interest and future Mrs. Claus and some other famous folklore figures including the Tooth Fairy (Art LeFleur) and the Easter Bunny (Jay Thomas). Michael Lembeck would also direct the third in the series THE SANTA CLAUSE 3: THE ESCAPE CLAUSE (2006) with Santa battling Jack Frost (Martin Short). It was an interesting idea but THE SANTA CLAUSE 3 is the weakest of the three films.

You would think Tim Allen would have had the time of his life making THE SANTA CLAUSE and playing the big guy but that was part of the problem. Allen had to wear a fat suit for the Santa scenes which was extremely uncomfortable and hot. THE SANTA CLAUSE was filmed in Canada in the summer not winter under hot movie lights. Thankfully Allen endured and THE SANTA CLAUSE is one of those rare, good modern holiday films that can stand beside the classics like Frank Capra's IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE (1946) and Michael Curtiz's WHITE CHRISTMAS (1954). And to think, if my son hadn't been born, I would have seen THE SANTA CLAUSE when it was originally released. Having to discover it a year later, I wouldn't change that for the world.